Looking for a Pet Honesty Allergy Support Alternative for Your French Bulldog?
Looking for a Pet Honesty Allergy Support Alternative for Your French Bulldog?
Pet Honesty Allergy Support is a soft chew with colostrum, turmeric, a 14-mushroom proprietary blend, fish-oil omega-3, quercetin and probiotics, one chew a day for a dog up to 25 lb, with no amounts printed for most of it. The closest alternative built for a French Bulldog is Frenchies vs Mushrooms: a food powder with seven mushroom extracts at 243 mg each, flax omega-3 instead of fish oil, organic turmeric and vitamin C, no chicken and no fish. Frenchies vs Mushrooms prints the amount of every mushroom and keeps fish out of the jar.
Quick verdict
Switch if your Frenchie reacts to fish, if you want to see milligrams instead of a proprietary blend, or if chews have not been working.
Stay with Pet Honesty if the chew is already working and your dog is fine with fish oil.
Pet Honesty Allergy Support vs Frenchies vs Mushrooms
| Pet Honesty Allergy Support (salmon) | Frenchies vs Mushrooms | |
|---|---|---|
| Form | Soft chew | Powder, 1 scoop on food |
| Mushrooms | Proprietary organic blend of 14 mushrooms, amounts not shown | 7 extracts, 243 mg each (Turkey Tail, Chaga, Cordyceps, Phellinus, Maitake, Reishi, Shiitake) |
| Omega-3 source | Fish oil (EPA/DHA) | Flax meal, 450 mg |
| Other actives | Colostrum (15% IgG), turmeric, astragalus, vitamin C, quercetin, zinc, apple cider vinegar, black pepper, vitamin E, 8-strain probiotics. Amounts not shown | Organic turmeric 150 mg, vitamin C 100 mg |
| Inactive ingredients | Pumpkin, sweet potato, oat flour, brewer's yeast, yuca, natural salmon flavor, coconut oil, vegetable glycerin, sunflower lecithin and others | Desiccated beef liver |
| Chicken, fish, soy? | Salmon flavor contains fish; chicken only in the Max Strength flavor; no soy | No chicken, no fish, no soy |
| Label cautions | May irritate the GI tract; not with blood thinners or stomach ulcers (their page) | Start sensitive stomachs on half a scoop (our page) |
| Guarantee | Not stated on the product page | 60 day love it or it's free |
Why Frenchie owners pick Frenchies vs Mushrooms
- Every mushroom has a number. 243 mg each of seven extracts. Pet Honesty lists 14 mushrooms as a proprietary blend with no amounts, so you cannot tell whether it is 10 mg or 1,000 mg of turkey tail.
- No fish anywhere. For the Frenchie whose paw licking started on a salmon kibble, that is the whole reason to switch.
- Short inactive list. One inactive ingredient (beef liver) against a dozen flours, yeasts and glycerins.
- Breed dosing. One scoop for a 25 lb adult, half for a puppy or a sensitive stomach. No weight bands.
- Guarantee printed on the page. 60 days, full jar, refund or discount.
Who should pick which
Stay with Pet Honesty if it is already working. A working supplement is not something to fix.
Switch to Frenchies vs Mushrooms if you suspect fish, if the chew did nothing after a full bag, or if you want to know exactly how much mushroom your dog is getting.
Either way, change one thing at a time and give it a full container before you decide.
Questions Frenchie owners ask
Why would a Frenchie owner leave Pet Honesty Allergy Support?
The three reasons we hear most: the dog is sensitive to fish and the chew is salmon based, the owner wants to see mushroom amounts instead of a proprietary blend, or the dog ate the chews for a bag and nothing changed. None of those make Pet Honesty a bad product; they make it the wrong fit for that dog.
Can I switch straight from Pet Honesty to Frenchies vs Mushrooms?
Yes. Finish the chews or stop them, then start Frenchies vs Mushrooms at half a scoop on food for three days, then one scoop. The two labels share turmeric and vitamin C, so do not run both at full dose at the same time.
Why does Frenchies vs Mushrooms use flax instead of fish oil?
Because a large share of itchy Frenchies are reacting to a protein, and fish is one of the common ones. Flax meal gives a plant omega-3 (450 mg per scoop) with no fish anywhere in the jar.
How long does a jar of Frenchies vs Mushrooms last?
60 scoops. At one scoop a day for a 25 lb adult that is about two months. A puppy on half a scoop gets about four months.
We compare what each company prints on its own product page. Supplements support normal body functions; they do not treat, cure or prevent disease. Ask your vet before starting any supplement, especially for a dog with a thyroid condition, on medication, pregnant or under 8 weeks.
Sources checked on October 13, 2026
Prices and ingredients change. These are the pages the numbers came from, read on that date. If one has moved, the newer page wins.